Please E-mail suggested additions, comments and/or corrections to Kent@MoreLaw.Com.

Help support the publication of case reports on MoreLaw

Date: 11-20-1998

Case Style: Central Cartage Co., et al. v. Terry L. Fewless, Susan Fewless, Susan A. Fewless d/b/a Skan Consulting; and Total Quality, Inc.

Case Number: 199433

Judge: Unknown

Court: Circuit Court, Ingham County, Michigan

Plaintiff's Attorney: Robert E. McFarland and Kathryn M. Niemer of Foster, Swift, Collins & Smith, P.C., Farmington Hills, Michigan

Defendant's Attorney: Andrew P. Abood of Abood Law, Lansing, Michigan

Description: Central is one of several wholly-owned transportation subsidiaries of CenTra. The majority of Central's business is in the automotive industry, transporting parts from surrounding states to various automobile plants in Michigan. Because Michigan is considered an "inbound" state, one of Central's goals is to produce business going out of Michigan so that its trucks do not travel outward empty.

Terry Fewless began working for Central in 1976, eventually becoming regional vice president of automotive sales. Fewless secured Wyeth-Ayerst Laboratories (Wyeth) as a customer for Central. Wyeth produced baby formula and other nutritional in a plant in Mason and needed to transport its products out of state; it was, therefore, an important account for Central. Various United States Department of Agriculture and Food and Drug Administration regulations require that Wyeth's infant formula stay within a certain temperature range. Because Central had only "dry vans," rather than more costly steel-lined temperature-controlled trailers, Wyeth permitted Central to transport Wyeth freight only within a relatively small area. Central used cargo heaters on the trucks when needed in the winter months, with limited success.

In 1991, Fewless made a "single source" proposal to Wyeth on Central's behalf, in an attempt to obtain brokerage fees. Fewless advised Central's owner/chief executive officer, Matty Moroun, of the potential for large revenues from Wyeth if Central were to obtain temperature-controlled trucks for more lengthy trips. According to Fewless, Moroun said that he was not interested, saying "That's not our type of business."

In the spring of 1992, Wyeth became concerned about a potential, nationwide railway strike. Representatives of Wyeth contacted Fewless for assistance in finding a temperature-controlled carrier who could handle Wyeth's freight on long interstate trips. Fewless learned that Navajo Express, one of Central's carriers for automotive parts, had a large fleet of temperature-controlled trailers and advised Navajo to contact Wyeth.

Navajo offered Fewless a commission for sending the Wyeth business its way, but Fewless declined, apparently recognizing that it would be inappropriate because he was an employee of Central. Wyeth continued to use Navajo after the railway strike ended, and Fewless' wife; Susan, set up SKAN, which received a six to seven percent commission on the Wyeth freight transported by Navajo.[fn4] Fewless never advised Moroun that Susan was going to be an agent for Navajo with regard to Wyeth freight or that she was receiving commission payments from Navajo.

Realizing that there was great potential for profit in the field of temperature-controlled trucking, Fewless incorporated TQI, applied for a property brokers license, and signed a lease for office space in anticipation of establishing his own third-party logistics company. Fewless testified that he did not actually solicit any business for TQI while he was an employee of Central, and this assertion was confirmed by representatives of both Wyeth and Navajo.

In early December 1992, when confronted with rumors that he had started another company, Fewless admitted that his wife had formed a company that was receiving revenues from Navajo. Fewless tendered a resignation letter to Moroun, in which he stated his intention to start his own logistics company and his desire to maintain a close relationship with Central. On December 7, 1992, Central terminated Fewless employment. Within a few months after Fewless left Central, TQI entered into written agreements with both Wyeth and Navajo.

Meanwhile, Central began losing more and more of Wyeth's business, which virtually ceased by the end of 1993. A representative of, Wyeth testified regarding several temperature-related service failures that required a quarantine of its product, as well as a marked deterioration in the cleanliness of Central's trailers and poor driver attitudes. Wyeth instituted a new policy that required transportation in a temperature-controlled environment to prevent product freezing. Wyeth's position was that it would have continued to use Central or P.A.M. if they had provided temperature-controlled trailers, competitive rates, and competitive service.

Plaintiffs filed a multiple count complaint against defendants, alleging breach of contract, a common-law obligation not to compete, intentional misrepresentation, innocent misrepresentation, silent fraud, conspiracy to commit fraud, interference with existing contractual relationships, interference with prospective business relations, interference with contractual relations, a right to an accounting, and breach of fiduciary duty.

Outcome: At the close of the evidence, the trial court granted defendants' motion for a direct verdict with regard to several claims and granted plaintiffs' motion for a direct verdict regarding their claim for $55,000 paid by Navajo to SKAN while Fewless remained employed by Central. The jury specifically found that Fewless did not beach his fiduciary duty to Central after his termination and returned a verdict of no cause of action on all remaining counts.

Plaintiff's Experts: Unknown

Defendant's Experts: Unknown

Comments: Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded by the Court of Appeals of Michigan. 591 N.W.2d 422 (Mich.App. 1998). The date shown above is the date of the appellate court decision and not the trial date.



Find a Lawyer

Subject:
City:
State:
 

Find a Case

Subject:
County:
State: