Defendant's Attorney: L. Earl Ogletree for Michael O'Brien, et al.
Description: Oklahoma City, personal injury lawyer represented Plaintiffs, who sued defendants on medical malpractice negligence theories claiming more than $10,000 in damages and/or injuries as a direct result of substandard medical care.
Plaintiff Loyd Green suffered a torn rotator cuff in his right shoulder. He was referred to Dr. Micahel Sean O'Brien, MD who performed a total shoulder replacement. Plaintiff claimed that the replacement shoulder was mispositioned and did not diagnose the mispositioning for 9 months.
Defendant denied that he was negligent and claimed that all medical care was within the standard of care.
Outcome: 12-07-2021
JUDGE OGDEN: CASE COMES ON FOR 2ND DAY OF JURY TRIAL: PARTIES ARE PRESENT AND ANNOUNCED READY: PLAINTIFF CALL THEIR FIRST WITNESS, MICHAEL SEAN O'BRIEN, SWORN IN, EXAMINED AND CROSS-EXAMINED: COURT IS ADORJNED UNTIL 12-08-2021 AT 9:00AM
--COURT REPORTER, MARILYN HODGEN IS PRESENT--
12-08-2021
JUDGE OGDEN: CASE COMES ON FOR 3RD DAY OF JURY TRIAL: PARTIES ARE PRESENT AND ANNOUNCED READY: PLAINTIFF CALL THEIR SECOND WITNESS, LOYD GREEN, SWORN IN, EXAMINED AND CROSS-EXAMINED: PLTF NOW CALLS THEIR NEXT WITNESS BY VIDEO DEPOSITION: COURT IS ADORJNED UNTIL 12-09-2021 AT 9:00AM
--COURT REPORTER, MARILYN HODGEN IS PRESENT-
12-09-2021
JUDGE OGDEN: CASE COMES ON FOR 4TH DAY OF JURY TRIAL: PARTIES ARE PRESENT AND ANNOUNCED READY: PLAINTIFF CALL THEIR FINAL WITNESS, TAMMY GREEN, SWORN IN, EXAMINED AND CROSS-EXAMINED: PLTF RESTS: DEFT MOVES FOR MOTIONS AND THEY ARE OVERRULED: DEFT CALLS THEIR 1ST WITNESS, SWORN IN, EXAMINED AND CROSS-EXAMINED: DEFT RESTS: COURT'S INSTRUCTION TO THE JURY: CLOSING ARGUMENTS MADE BY BOTH PARTIES: JURY RETIRES TO DELIBERATE: RETURNS WITH ANSWER TO JURY INTERROGATORY IS 'NO', ALSO RETURNS VERDICT AND FINDS IN FAVOR OF DEFENDANT MICHAEL SEAN O'BRIEN ET AL: JURY IS THANKED FOR THEIR SERVICE AND DISCHARGED
--COURT REPORTER, MARILYN HODGEN IS PRESENT--
12-09-2021
JUDGE OGDEN: JUDGMENT FOR THE DEFENDANT
Plaintiff's Experts:
Defendant's Experts: Dr. Lewis L. Shi, M.D., Chicago, Illinois
Comments: Dr. Mark Mighell, M.D., Tampa, Florida